First, I owe you an apology for this episode arriving later than planned! I really wanted to release it on November 16, so thank you for waiting—and for celebrating my birthday with one of the creepiest houses we have ever covered.
From the street, the Sallie House looks like an ordinary white home in Atchison, Kansas. But inside, visitors have reported child-sized handprints, toys moving on their own, whispers coming from empty rooms, violent scratches, shadow figures, and something deeply unsettling waiting in the basement.
The legend claims the home is haunted by Sallie, a six-year-old girl who allegedly died during a painful emergency surgery. But when the historical evidence behind Sallie’s story begins to fall apart, we are left with an even more frightening question: If Sallie was never there, what was tormenting the Pickman family?
In this episode, we explore the Sallie House legend, the terrifying experiences of Tony and Debra Pickman, the entities investigators believe still occupy the home, and the skeptical explanations behind one of America’s most infamous hauntings.
Was Sallie an innocent child trapped inside the house? Was she being used by something more dangerous—or was the entire legend created to attract paranormal tourism?
Listen now, and decide for yourself.
Content Warning
This episode includes discussions of a child’s alleged death, painful medical procedures, physical attacks, scratches and injuries, sleep paralysis, threats of violence, and paranormal activity involving an infant.
Share Your Story
Have you ever visited the Sallie House—or experienced something you still cannot explain?
Submit your personal spooky story at HauntedPod.com or email hauntedpod@gmail.com for a chance to have it featured on the show.
Follow the Show
- Instagram: @itshauntedwhatnow
- X/Twitter: @itshaunted_pod
- Website: HauntedPod.com
If you enjoyed the episode, please leave a positive review on Apple Podcasts or your podcast player of choice. It really helps others discover the show!
Credits
Production assistance by Jesse Hawke of The Inky Pawprint.
Original music and audio production by Nico of The Inky Pawprint. Find him at @wetalkofdreams or wetalkofdreams.com.
Until next time…did you hear that?
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
